Visitors

Showing posts with label Dr Shabir Choudhary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dr Shabir Choudhary. Show all posts

Thursday, 21 December 2023

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 355 of 2023

1034hrs:

When the 'boot is on the other foot' it is difficult for our people to recognise the requirements of a 'peace strategy' as opposed to a 'conflict strategy', whereby our people have traditionally fell 'lock, stock and barrel' for the latter without thinking much about the consequences.

....

As intimated earlier, we have begun scrutinising the workings of local government organs in the tehsil (subdivision) of Sehnsa, my home tehsil. Today was our maiden visit to the 'Department of Alms', described in Urdu as 'Tehsil Zakat wa Ashar Committee':


Earlier, here's the video made at home today before venturing out: 

..
Here's the video after our maiden discussion at the 'Department of Alms':

....

'Your Rule' & 'My Rule' = 'Public Rule' = Popular Sovereignty

We have embarked on an advanced stage at Jammu Chowk in Sehnsa today:


..

As with our previous public sit-in protests in Kotli - Shaheed Chowk (2022) and Dadyaal - Maqbool Bhat Shaheed Chowk (2022 to 2023) we will try and provide a photo of our presence at Sehnsa - Jammu Chowk on each day that we attend. It should be noted that this presence is very different from the previous two, on many counts. As a hint, the earlier two were on our own initiative and our presence was not only daily but at times had to extend to 24 hours, while the initiative at Sehnsa has been taken by the public in Sehnsa itself in mid August 2023 and our presence is not strictly daily. In short, the public has finally woken up in 2023 and taken veritable responsibility:


....

Here's an analysis by Dr Shabir Choudhary of where the Awaami Action Committee - AJK stands vis a vis the Government of AJK, followed by my response:

Action Committee V Azad Kashmir Government

Dr Shabir Choudhry
London
21 December 2023

1. I have no doubt in sincerity of the Action Committee members, who were selected to hold dialogue with the Conciliation Committee established by the Government of Azad Kashmir.

2. However, by looking at the handwritten 2 paragraph Urdu document, it appears that the Conciliation Committee has already won the battle; but the war is still to be won.

3. Sadly, the representatives of the Action Committee failed to discharge their responsibilities and protect genuine demands and fundamental rights of the suffering people of Azad Kashmir.

4. I can understand constraints of the Government selected Conciliation Committee; and I am also cognizant with the legal and constitutional  (Lent Officers, Act 74, Ministry of Kashmir Affairs, The Karachi Pact, Kashmir Council, GOC Murree and the secret agencies) under which they have to conduct affairs of this region controlled by Pakistan.

5. Despite all the checks, controls and restrictions their loyalty must be with the people of Azad Kashmir, and they must protect and enhance fundamental rights of the people. 

6. The Action Committee should demand that there must be a national grid in Azad Kashmir, and all the electricity, around 4,000 Megawatt, produced in Azad Kashmir must go to Azad Kashmir national grid instead of the Pakistani national grid.

7. Our electricity consumption is between 350 to 400 Megawatt, and the rest WAPDA should purchase from Azad Kashmir so that we can also benefit from our resources.

8. The WAPDA or Pakistan should pay us back all the money they illegally and forcefully collected from us in the name of Neelam Jhelum project.

9. All the Dams built in Azad Kashmir must be under the control of Azad Kashmir Government.

10. All other resources of our region should also be under control of Azad Kashmir.

11. All estates belonging to the erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir must be controlled by the Azad Kashmir.

12. Problems of Azad Kashmiri expatriates must be resolved. They must be accorded with all necessary facilities at all the airports.

13. All citizens of Azad Kashmir must be provided travelling documents so that they can travel abroad and also visit their motherland.

14. Army must limit themselves to their barracks and vacate mingling with residential areas.

15. The current ‘agreement’ with the Conciliation Committee is inadequate and too vague, and that will strengthen the position of the Government.

16. As the agreement stands, my apprehension is that the Government with the help of the Conciliation Committee is playing games with the Action Committee; and their real agenda was and is to delay matters and take the momentum out of the Movement which has massive public support.

17. This vagueness will be interpreted by experts of the Azad Kashmir Government to benefit the authorities and Pakistan at the expense of the ordinary citizens of Azad Kashmir who are suffering because of the exploitative policies and a pro Pakistan system of governance.

18. The Action Committee must induct some experts who can help and advise them.

19. There is no mechanism to implement the final agreement. What action could be taken if the government refuses to implement some of the conditions. 

END.

..

My response on 22/12/2023

Have read and agree. Pressure can be put on the Awami Action Committee to broaden their consultative process with the public (especially experts in various relevant fields) and to draw tangibles from their interaction with the AJK 'government'. 

That is, focus on what is possible now - to gain those usurped rights which can be delivered straight away without complexity and to press on GovtAJK to prepare process for your point about selling all electricity through a national AJK grid including a mechanism on how that national wealth will be utilised in AJK. Would it be confined to subsidised bills for our population or will the Govt share that new found income with the public? 

Examples like Norway come to mind.

Legal and constitutional matters should be phased in within the engagement which should continue and not tempt the Awami Action Committee into making a 'full and final' deal.

This has to be a sustained exercise. The public should not forego their sit-in protests at any cost. They are a guarantor of regaining the territory of AJK for its people.

Otherwise, we will end up back at square one.

End..

....

Wednesday, 20 December 2023

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 354 of 2023

1114hrs:

We will be digging deeper into the functioning of local governance in our home tehsil (subdivision) Sehnsa over the next few days, weeks and months.

....

I shall use the following words written by Dr Shabir Choudhary himself to introduce the following video:

A dialogue with Tanveer Ahmed. Make Azad Kashmir military free zone. Peaceful struggle to continue.

We don't need protection from the Pakistani army. There shall be no war with India. Promotion of trade, peace and regional cooperation is needed.


....

Saturday, 19 November 2022

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 323 of 2022

1027hrs:

Day 167 at Maqbool Bhat Shaheed Square - Dadyaal.

0759hrs

Attendance = 100%
Punctuality = 62%
104 days on time or early of 167
Punctuality surplus = 18 minutes 
Punctuality Consistency Status = 14 days

....

The Malik Waseem 'Land & People' reference case has taken a new turn, especially after civil society (X-LOC) made contact with the actual inheritors of this concerned evacuee property earlier this month. Many thanks to Romi Sharma in particular:


This has obviously shaken the land mafia of Muzaffarabad and their accomplices within the so-called 'nationalist' fraternity in the capital, both at home and abroad.

Dr Shabir Choudhary zeroes in on this point in the following video:

"Pakistan is sending the wrong message to the people of Jammu and Kashmir. 
Dispute of Waseem Malik, resident of Muzaffarabad, must be resolved honourably so that he can care for his wife and children."


(Update) 1853hrs on 20/11/2022:

Dr Shabir Choudhary continues with Malik Waseem's theme in a consecutive video, while also responding to some feedback:

"Accession treaty and India’s obligations. Who is responsible to protect the rights of Waseem Malik?
Under the obligations of United Nations Security Council Resolutions Pakistan cannot violate fundamental rights of people of Jammu and Kashmir."


....

Thursday, 21 November 2019

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 325 of 2019

0003hrs:

Absent mindedness denied me posting an entry for Day 324 even though the following - in brackets - had been written according to the timeline indicated:


n.b. diary for today viz. 21/11/19 - Day 325 of 2019 can be read below yesterday's diary

(1805hrs - 20/11/19 - Day 324 of 2019):


Agar Hindustaan soney ki chirya hay to Jammu Kashmir heeray, moti ki kaan hay......aur bahut kuch


English translation: 


If Hindustaan (India + Pakistan + Bangladesh + Myanmar etc.) is a golden sparrow then Jammu Kashmir is a mine of diamonds and pearls.....and much more)

So, the day started with me waking up at home in Kokoi for the first time in a long while, which is across the road from Gurutta where I was born, in my Naani's home. All my possessions are still scattered everywhere from the raid on the 24th of October.

Whenever I do visit my ancestral village I make a point of visiting my Naani's grave, reading Surah Yasin from the Quran while also plucking out the weeds that seem to grow more around her grave than anyone else's. 

My local mechanic was kind enough to bring my - now fixed - vehicle home so that I could then pay him before proceeding northwards to where I've been expected 2 days ago. My destination for the day was Dheerkot where some of our co-citizens had been waiting for me all day. I couldn't get there before 2000hrs. I had to pick up a co-citizen from Rawalakot too while yet another co-citizen had travelled especially for this court case from Dadyaal via Pakistan to Dheerkot.

I had announced soon after being released from jail on the 31st of October that I needed security as well as research assistants to take our public interest work forward. I could no longer afford to visit Muzaffarabad alone. Preparations and contingencies needed to be set-up. Hence, taking a dozen or so people with me to our court hearing in Muzaffarabad tomorrow.

.....

Meanwhile, a heap of crimes committed by the Pakistani army and its agencies are surfacing in AJK. This is just one ghastly example:




Here's an English translation of the letter in the FB image above:


For the attention of Esquire - Tanveer Ahmed Researcher


Subject: Redress, action against terrorism 


Your Excellency


I wish to bring to your attention that this petitioner is a resident of the LOC at Bandli. I am in the line of Indian fire on a daily basis. There is a Pakistani army artillery camp near our home. It was from this camp that on the 7th of November (2019) at the dead of night our under-aged daughter Samiya Anwar daughter of Muhammad Anwar resident of Hamlet Maanpura was kidnapped by soldier Raashid Ali, with the assistance of other soldiers.


When we found out after a while, we immediately notified the army camp nearby. They investigated and it was discovered that our daughter was at an individual named Raashid Ali's house in Hassan Abdaal Rawalpindi Pakistan. In reference to this, the Major of (Army) Camp Bandli and this unit's Colonel promised us that they would return our daughter within 2 days in all circumstances. Further, that even if a nikaah (marriage according to Islam) had been conducted they would obtain a divorce and return her forthwith. They also said that the Pakistani army is the guardian of Kashmiri dignity, unlike the Indian army which which acts as brigands where women are concerned.  


Many days have passed however. All we are witnessing are deceptive maneuvers. On the basis of humanity we implore your excellency to return our daughter to us. That the brigand of our dignity soldier Raashid Ali be punished for terrorism and for taking unconstitutional steps.


Thank you


Copy to copy


..............


1) For the attention of esquire Chief of Army Staff GHQ Rawalpindi

2) For the attention of esquire DG ISI GHQ Rawalpindi
3) For the attention of esquire Corp Commander GHQ Rawalpindi
4) GOC Jhelum Pakistan

Petitioner


Raja Muhammad Anwar son of Baaqir Ali - Signature


Identity Card Number: 81202-7921723-7


Resident of Bandli Mohalla Maanpura near Pakistan artillery camp Bandli P.O. and tehsil: Khuiratta district: Kotli - AJK


Brother Arshad - Phone Number - 03495476052


Brother Manzoor - Phone Number - 03474311897

End of English translation of letter......


For those of you who want to read it in Urdu but can't make it out properly can read the Roman transliteration below:


Bakhidmat janaab - Tanveer Ahmed Muhaqiq


Unwaan daad rassi, dehshat gardi ke khilaaf karwai


Janaab e Ali


Guzarish e khidmat hay sail LOC Bandli ka rihaishi hoo. Aye roz Indian army ki firing ki zad me hoo. Hamaarey gharo ke qareeb Pakistan army artillery ka camp hay. Pakistan army artillery camp se sipahi Raashid Ali aur deegar faujiyo ki madad se 7 November 2019 raat ki taareeqi me hamaari kam umar beti Samiya Anwar dukhtar Muhammad Anwar Saakin Mohalla Maanpura se uthaa kar le gaye.


Kuch der baad humey maloom huwa to hum ne foran qareebi fauji camp ko itilaa di to unho ne jaanch partaal ki maloom huwa ke Raashid Ali naami shaks ke ghar Hassan Abdaal Rawalpindi Pakistan beti ki mojoodgi paayi gayi jis par Major Camp Bandli aur is unit ke Colonel ne har soorat beti ko do din ke andar humey waapas deney ka waada kiya ke agar nikaah bhi huwa ho to talaaq ke saath beti aap ko dengey aur kaha ke Pakistan army Kashmiriyo ki izzato ki muhaafiz hay naakey Indian army ki tarah aurato ke lootere hain. Lekin kai din guzarney ke baawajood taal matol kar rahey hain. Janaab se insaani hamdardi guzaarish hay ke hamaari beti humey waapas di jaey. Aur izzat ke looterey sipahi Raashid Ali ko dehshat gardi ghair aini ikdaam ki saza di jaye. 


Shukrya


Copy to copy


..............


1) Baakhidmat janaab chief of army staff GHQ Rawalpindi

2) Baakhidmat janaab DG ISI GHQ Rawalpindi
3) Baakhidmat janaab Corp Commander GHQ Rawalpindi
4) GOC Jhelum Pakistan

Darkhwaast guzaar 


Raja Muhammad Anwar wald Baaqir Ali - Signature


Shanaakhti Card Number: 81202-7921723-7


Saakin Bandli Mohalla Maanpura nazd Pakistan artillery camp Bandli P.O. aur tehsil Khuiratta zila Kotli AJK


Arshad Bhai - Phone Number - 03495476052


Manzoor Bhai - Phone Number - 03474311897

End of Roman transliteration......


Here's some analysis on the issue above. Many thanks to Dr. Shabir Choudhary for taking this up: 




(Update 11/02/20 at 1019hrs although the following video was made on the 11th of January i.e. 11/01/20):




......

Opening Bal. 48,940 (20/11/19 - i.e. Day 324 of 2019)

X:
30,000 - Gave to uncle for rebuilding wall (from 50K received from mother in UK y'day)
11,000 - Paid up for engine repair (paid 1,000 yesterday - total 12K paid)
1,000 - DR - Mechanic (ref. from 2010 - bal. 3,000)
550 - USB lead & Samsung battery (with 50 rs discount)
30 - Scan, copy and email of documents
1,500 - Diesel
250 - B & H cig.
500 - Co-citizen for leaving his work to accompany us to Muzaffarabad
20 - Tyre pressure

Y:
(500 - for my full time assistant from BBH as he came to join me from home)

Breakdown of part 2 of Engine work:
Water Body - 2,500
Timing Belt - 1,600
Silicon - 200
Tappit Cover Jain - 350
Heater plug - 600
Engine Oil - Rimula D - 2,500
Cam Seal - 300
Cylinder Collar - 100
Paraffin oil + Cloth - 500
Labour - 4,000
Total - 12,650
discount - 650
Paid - 12,000

(Mechanic forgot to include 1,500 for head gasket, which I will pay for the next time I see him)

Other material/in kind support: 
20 - Tyre pressure - RT
Breakfast at uncle's - KSA
Lunch of meat/roti and kahwa - SBH
600 - For the evening meal of potha kaleji, tindey, keema, tea and kahwa for 5 late in the evening - DL

Abbreviations:

Bal. - Balance
X - Outgoing
K - 1,000
UK - United Kingdom
DR - Debt Repayment
rs. Pakistani rupees
cig. - cigarettes
Y - Incoming
BBH - Bagh (District & Tehsil)
RT - Rawalakot
KSA - Sehnsa 
SBH - Baloch 
DL - Dadyaal

Closing Bal. 4,090
.....

(0700hrs - 21/11/19 - Day 325 of 2019):

I'm due in court today for my hearing in reference to an allegation of trying to commit suicide at Laal Chowk on the evening of the 25th of October this year (2019). Reference can be made to a similar court case invoked by Pakistan's clandestine agencies - forever in the dark shadows of public life in AJK - by using the local police in Leepa in August 2015. The learned judge then described in his verdict that the court's time had been wasted. Here's a reference to the decision made on the 18th of March 2016, at district courts Hattian Bala.


I didn't sleep much today as I had much work pending since running around my vehicle and its travails over the past few days. 4 hours I obtained in total. Over breakfast given by my hosts in Dheerkot there were some good searching questions over the local IG (Inspector General) issue. 

Diesel in vehicle finished about 8 kilometres short of Muzaffarabad and we were already getting late for the court hearing. It s just as well that I had a full-time assistant with me and it was an added bonus that the fuel station wasn't too far either. There are many things in my vehicle that do not work or need attention. The fuel gauge is just one of them. The vehicle had drank more diesel than I envisaged. A leaking exhaust or rain could be a factor in miscalculation.

A feeling of lethargy overtook me especially after lunch. It hadn't stopped raining since the morning either. My Dheerkot friends requested that I drop them at Kohalla. Despite my condition and an even worse condition of my vehicle (exhaust was leaking and wipers were not working) I was duty bound to obey them. 

In the interim, we all discussed how to proceed with our public interest activity. I explained that as long as we are all utilised according to our capacity we will get to our destination.

We returned to Muzaffarabad from Kohalla in fading light and intermittent rain. Only one headlight is working, the front windows do not close, the wipers weren't working but operating in such challenging conditions is almost routine and we take everything in our stride.

We needed a cosy fire to repel the weather and that was our next target in Muzaffarabad. Over discussion, our friend from the UK said we shouldn't antagonise the UK government over their role in J & K. I responded that we appreciate everything that society and system has done for us but we cannot take up arms against India and Pakistan. The UK would have take its fair share of responsibility if we were to succeed in a peaceful, ethical, democratic and legal fight against our neighbours. After all, it was the departing British Empire under a Labour government in the UK that facilitated India and Pakistan's entry into Jammu & Kashmir.

An amazing event happened this evening: 

I shared my remaining walnuts and a couple of packets of biscuits with my co-citizens around the fire. Without being aware of the contents in my bag, everybody got an equal share of walnuts and biscuits. On the third and final round, there was just one extra biscuit to spare. We all felt that was miraculous as there were about 10 of us.

We're staying in a hotel tonight. When I used to come to Muzaffarabad as a single activist, I could adjust pretty much anywhere. Now I have a full-time assistant to look after. Expenses will inevitably rise.

.....

This is what I wrote for the court a few days ago:

This was a carefully considered event to wake up the public and government of AJK alike, on the subject of security in AJK. 


At no point in time did I put my life or anyone else's life in danger.


Contrary to the allegation of suicide put before a court in Muzaffarabad, everything I've done in this territory is pro-life. What I am struggling for and want to achieve needs years of further research and struggle. My only chance of succeeding is if I live to complete what I want to do. 


A public protest should always be to address an attention deficit, particularly in matters relating to the security of a territory, in our case AJK. 


We can no longer tolerate a system of governance run by shadows without a trace. Tomorrow, they will adopt even more brutal tactics to submerge us into Pakistan.


We - the inheritors of AJK - need to get a grip on the requisite criteria for accountability before it is too late.


A local IG will put us on the right road to OBMs (Ownership-Building Measures), future public protests will be more engaging and fulfill their purpose of building a functional bridge between the AJK public and its own government. 


I've been hitting the nail on the head with increasing velocity over the past month in particular. That is why my ancestral home in Sehnsa was raided on the 24th of October. If I can't bring the suspects before a court of law, I have to address the public at large somehow.


If the AJK government was serious in developing the dialogue on the subject of installing a local IG in public interest, I would have gladly climbed back down and there would have been no reason to activate the 'rescue services'. It was akin to making a calm situation potentially volatile.


As it became clear while sitting atop the tower at Laal Chowk for 6 hours, the AJK government made it clear that the subject of installing a local IG was out of the question.


The government or more pointedly the shadows running our government - without legal reference or any form of accountability - had to be pushed to the limit and I did that. 


We want to live life to the full but on terms with a local constitutional reference.


Our dignity is in our own hands.


End...


Translated into Roman Urdu, it reads as:


Ye Muzaffarabad ki adaalat ke liye bil-khusoos aur AJK ki awaam ke liye bil-amoom paigham hay.


Ye aik sanjeedgi se soch kar amal tha AJK ki awaam aur hukumat dono ko jagaaney ke liye, AJK me tahaffuz ke mozoo par.


Kisi bhi waqt me ne apni ya kisi aur ki zindagi ko khatrey me nahi daala.


Us khudkashi ke ilzaam ke bar-aqs jo Muzaffarabad ki adaalat ke saamney rakha gaya, jo kuch bhi me ne kiya is dharti me wo zindagi ke haq me kiya. Jin ahdaaf ke liye me jad o jehd kar raha hoo aur haasil karna chahta hoo, un ko mazeed kai saal darkaar hain tehqeeq aur jad o jehd me. Kamyabi ka moqa usi soorat me hay ke me zinda rahoo is kaam ko mukammal karney ke liye.


Awaami ihtijaaj hamesha adam tawajo ka saamna karney ke liye hona chahiye, bil khusoos un maamalaat par jo aik dharti ke tahaffuz ke mutallaq ho, jo hamaarey tanaazur me AJK ki dharti hay.


Ab hum mazeed aisey nizaam ko bardaasht nahi kar saktey jo saaye chalayen jin ki khoj lagaana bhi namumkin ho. Aaney waaley kal ko ye is se bhi zyaada bathar hikmat amli ikhtyaar karengey humey Pakistan me zam karney ke liye.


Hum - jo AJK ke waaris hain - ko ashad zaroorat hay ke hum qaaboo paaye un qwaif par jo darkaar hain ehtesaab ke liye, is se qabl ke bahut der hojaye.


Aik maqaami IG humey us sadaq pe daal ne me madad karega jo humey malkiyat saazi ki taraf le jaye, is ke baad awaami ehtejaaj zyaada maaney khez hongey aur aik amli pull tameer hojayega AJK ki awaam aur us ki apni hukumat ke darmiyan.


Is pichley maheeney se bilkhusos me barthi huwi shidat se qeel ko teek sar pe maar raha hoo (mahaawaratan). Isi liye mera abaahi ghar Sehnsa me daaka para 24 October ko. Agar me mulzimaan ko court ke saamne haazir nahi karwa sakta, phir mujhe kissi na kissi zariye se awaam ke saamney baat rakhni padegi.


Agar awaami mufaad me AJK ki hukumat sanjeeda hoti maqaami IG ko tainaat karney ke mozoo par, phir me khushi khushi (tower se) neechay aajaata aur rescue sevices ko muttahariq karney ki koi zaroorat na hoti. Ye goya aisa tha ke aik puraman mahol ko mumkina taur par ishtyaal diya jaey.


Laal Chowk ke tower par 6 ghantey se baitey huwey ye baat waazey huwi ke AJK ki hukumat ke liye muqaami IG ko tainaat karney ke mozoo ko cherney ka sawaal hi nahi paida hota.


Hukumat ya dar-asal jo saaye hamaari hukumat ko chala rahey hay - beghair qanooni hawaaley se ya kissi qism ke ehtesaab ke dairey me aatey huwey - ko un ki hudood tak keenchna zaroori tha aur wo me ne kiya.


Hum zindagi jee bhar ke guzaarna chahtey hain lekin aik maqaami aini hawaaley ke saath.



Hamaara waqaar hamaarey hi haath me hay.

End of statement...


.....


Opening Bal. 4,090

X:
60 - Kahwa x 3
500 (plus 20 by Assistant from 500 he received y'day) - Diesel
100 - Rickshaw fare for getting diesel
250 - B & H cig.
70 - Kahwa and tea x 3
1,000 - Diesel
410 - RT co-citizens return fare & expenses
130 - 13 print-outs
27 - 9 copies
1,000 - Hotel room

Other material/in kind support: 
200 - Breakfast - channey. roghni naan and half-fry eggs - DT
1,000 - Lunch - assorted....dhaal, gosht, sazi and tea for 9 people - DL
100 - Kulchas - DL 

Abbreviations:

Bal. - Balance
X - Outgoing
cig. - cigarettes
RT - Rawalakot
DT - Dheerkot
DL - Dadyaal
rs. Pakistani rupees

Closing Bal. 543
....

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 278 of 2026

1239hrs: Day 123 had a rhythm to it and a pattern. Most of AJK (including most of its entry points from the State of Pakistan) have been shu...