Visitors

Showing posts with label Media & Diplomacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Media & Diplomacy. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 315 of 2026

1731hrs:

Day 160 and today I affirm to do everything (within a peaceful framework) to resolve this unnecessary conflict by Day 200. Of course, many thousands of us have done a lot in these past 160 days but we need to move into 4th & 5th gear during the next 40 days, especially in terms of our constitutional/legal and diplomatic strategy.

We know the Pakistani State is deeply frustrated and so they should be. While they continue to try and bolster their offensive, they are even considering air attacks to break what is effectively the people's authority in the districts of Poonch & Sudhnoti.

Today's Instagram notes:

Day 160 of Pakistan's latest illegal war on Jammu & Kashmir 

(Wed 11 Nov - Day 315 of 2026) 

The Pakistanis continue to make errors of frustration in their military operation. The more errors they make the more the public of AJK's disgust becomes apparent. They have ordered a further fleet of armoured vehicles from their country and are even contemplating air attacks if they continue to fail. 

Even at this mature stage of the conflict, the UK Government is still pretending to avoid its historic, ethical & legal responsibility towards this region. It cannot just confine its concern to British nationals here, of whom there are quite a few. 

While trying to ensure that the 2nd minute of each day's broadcast concentrates on constitutionalism, I am still struggling to apportion appropriate time. However, practice makes perfect and if our people can connect the right dots in history, we will be able to prepare that legal petition against the UK Government. 

Meanwhile, we will continue to discuss, debate, distill & dispel any misgivings about the subjects of #WarandPeace - especially from a Jammu Kashmir & Allied (areas) #JKA people's referenced perspective.

Further details to supplement the discussion in this video are available in my daily weblog at: 

tanveerandkashmir.blogspot.com

#Conflict2PeaceStrategyJKA

Link

....

Friday, 29 August 2025

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 241 of 2025

1444hrs:

A very lax past 24 hours, reflected in the timing of today's post which is even later than yesterday.

Family commitments have kept me engaged otherwise, although that can never be an excuse to not conduct all daily duties in a timely manner.

....

I was requested to draft a brief summary of the people's narrative from a historical perspective up to the present day; for the purposes of politicians, diplomats and other monitors of this territory that we describe as Jammu Kashmir & Allied (areas) or JKA for short:

The Terms ‘Jammu’ & ‘Kashmir’

Although written history can be traced back at least a couple of thousand years, the terms ‘Jammu’ & ‘Kashmir’ came together at the ‘Treaty of Amritsar’ on the 16th of March 1846, emerging as a result of the ‘Treaty of Lahore’ a week earlier. These were a series of events that signalled the downfall of the Ranjeet Singh era and the ascendancy of the British Indian colonial empire.

Both regions being adjacent to each other (viz. Jammu & Kashmir), one can trace a fluidity (like many other parts of the world) whereby each region in different eras would have had a different shape depending on its influence and relative power. No doubt, the term ‘Kashmir’ has been more widely known and used throughout history compared to ‘Jammu’.  

A lot of modern historians have tended to classify the history of the region using the terminology of religious identity. For example, there was a Hindu era pre Buddhist era (3rd century BCE to the 8th century CE) before another Hindu era emerged in the 8th century. Thereafter began the Muslim era in the 14th century viz. 1320 CE.  

Throughout history, the region has generally remained independent and this is exemplified through the writings of Pandit Kalhana in Rajatarangini (The chronological history of Kings) first published in 1148-49 CE. This historical account is generally described as the first of such in the whole Indian sub-continent & surrounding areas.

Pushing forward towards the modern day, it is generally noted by historians that the region of Kashmir lost its independence to the ascendant Mughal Indian empire in 1586 CE, followed by the Afghans who ruled this region from 1752 to 1819 before Sikh rule under Ranjeet Singh coincided with the gradual accumulation of territory by Gulab Singh, using Jammu as his power base. 

Birth of the State of Jammu & Kashmir

This is what then led to the formation of the State of Jammu & Kashmir (Referred to as J & K here on) in 1846, under British suzerainty.

Gulab Singh of Jammu and his family had prospered under Sikh Rule, signified by accumulation of territory up to Tibet (Ladakh), including Baltistan and other areas surrounding what is the Kashmir Valley. With the demise of Ranjeet Singh in 1838 began a series of in-fighting over succession and as the family of Gulab Singh also got caught up in these intrigues, they gradually made distance from what was left of the Sikh Empire and transferred their allegiance to the ascendant British colonial power. These events eventually facilitated the Treaty of Amritsar in 1846 (upon defeat of the remnants of the Sikh Empire by the British) as a quid pro quo between Gulab Singh and the British.

In turn, what was now termed as ‘Dogra Rule’ (indicating the region of Jammu where Gulab Singh and his successors originated from) developed their rule over what became c. 85,000 square miles of territory, including the regions of Gilgit Baltistan, Ladakh, the Kashmir Valley, Aksai Chin (Tibet Ha adjacent to the territory of Tibet), Jammu and what is today AJK (essentially splintered from the regions of the Kashmir Valley & Jammu).        

Although rule between 1846 and 1947 remained autocratic and harsh by some accounts, it remained consistent and stable. By the emergence of the 3rd successor to Gulab Singh (after his son Ranbir Singh followed in turn by his son Pratap Singh) Hari Singh was the nephew of Pratap SIngh (as the latter didn’t have any children) and was comparatively modern minded, introducing various socio-economic reforms including a definition of citizenship (State Subject Rule 20 April 1927), compulsory education and the introduction of a parliament (conducting 3 elections between 1934 and 1947 albeit with limited adult franchise). It is also important to note that bilateral agreements made between the State of J & K and British India were more balanced in terms & conditions while being protective of the territory of J & K, compared to all agreements made between post 1947 politicians and India & Pakistan. Examples include the Upper Jhelum Water Canal Agreement of 1904 and the Gilgit Lease Agreement of 1935.

It is also important to acknowledge that the public (or subjects under an autocratic dynasty) played a significant part in activism which led to some of the reforms described above.

Failure or Success of Outside Intervention?

It is within this framework ‘autocracy vs democracy’ that the rights movement pre 1947 should be understood rather than from a religious identity prism (viz. Hindu autocrat vs Muslim majority subjects), which tends to play into the 2 nation theory that the British colonial setup worked so successfully to establish post 1857 (Indian Independence Movement). This had led to the experiment of partitioning Bengal in 1905 and the Minto Morley Reforms of 1909 that created separate electorates for Hindus and Muslims in British India. These strategies to control the ‘locals’ compelled colonial subjects to conceptualise their rights based on their religious identity and perceive their fellow compatriots as the ‘other’, rather than the colonial power manipulating them.

What essentially should have been a peaceful transfer of power from ‘autocracy to democracy’ coinciding with British colonial departure from the region in 1947 and the end of British suzerainty in J & K, was converted into a question of accession to either India or Pakistan. The goalposts had been changed. Both the autocrat and his former subjects were marginalised in the process.

The United Nations was invoked to create a conflict resolution framework after both Indian and Pakistani troops under British command (at different intervals and under differing pretexts) were sent into the State of J & K to ostensibly protect the local population. 
It is important to note that the notion of asking the people (through a plebiscite) based on a non-binding conflict resolution framework that sough voluntary withdrawal of troops from both sides; was both a convenient way for Britain to avoid accountability and for India & Pakistan to cement their respective presence in the State of J & K, which endures to date.           
Indigenous Freedom Struggle Post 1947

With the autocrat (Hari Singh) adeptly thwarted from retaining the independence of the State of J & K and his former subjects lured into a split between an Indian (National Congress via National Conference & Sheikh Abdullah) and a Pakistani (Muslim League via Muslim Conference & Sardar Ibrahim), while simultaneously being given the impression that the United Nations would imminently resolve this matter, gradually transpired as an ‘eyewash’ for the people. 

Their rights struggle which was many decades old and for some communities even over a century old, was now tied in a straightjacket, with intermittent yet regular conflict between India & Pakistan, ensuring mounting casualties of the local population and apparently nobody even acknowledging their cries in 2025.   

Various freedom icons (Maqbool Butt being the most prominent) and rights movements have emerged to date, to try and help their compatriots break free of these modern chains of slavery; characterised by a structural absence of freedom of expression, association, assembly & movement on both sides of the divide. The Chinese encroachment into 17% of the State and looming ecological disasters throughout the region, only add to the complexities: which if pre 1947 - the autocratic ruler and his subjects had come to an understanding together - would have ensured a geopolitically neutral territory adopting the highest forms of direct democracy (surpassing the standards set by Switzerland) in a region which is most certainly - in relative terms – the most precious and thus sought after territory in the world, on account of its geographic location and the resources (particularly downhill inclined fresh water) flowing through it. 

Continued external manipulation would ensure indefinite multipolar conflict and internal strangulation of aspirations, while an internal political process without external influence based on the stakeholders binding each other into a contract clarifying each other’s rights & responsibilities (particularly over water management), would provide the most feasible opportunities for peace & prosperity of the whole region, which ultimately accounts for half the world’s population.         

....

The above brief historical summary of where the people (descendants of former State Subjects of Jammu Kashmir & Allied areas) find themselves in 2025; was written on the 29th of August 2025 by Tanveer Ahmed, an independent action-oriented public policy researcher - working un-interrupted on-the-ground in AJK since April 2005 - operating through direct public funding of the people of this territory, in an inclusive & equitable manner.  

....

Tuesday, 11 April 2023

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 101 of 2023

2245hrs:

We are engaging meaningfully with all our co-citizens from all backgrounds and regions from almost all parts of Jammu Kashmir & Allied areas.

This is a good omen.

....

Meanwhile, there is diplomatic activity conducted from AJK that should gradually assist in clarifying our sovereign status. On a personal level, I do not subscribe to pan-Islamism and have always maintained a strictly neutral stance in reference to the geopolitics of the world but it is important to highlight the concerns and aspirations of our people and how they engage with the world.

 

We haven't left this domain to Pakistan to freely manoeuvre as it pleases or as its interests dictate. The Pakistanis have deferred to the will of the people of Jammu Kashmir & Allied areas (JKA) in their constitution (ref. Article 257). They need to uphold their constitution in practice:

The following is a statement released by Quayyum Raja, founding chairman of the Centre for Jammu Kashmir Public Diplomacy:

Iran's embassies all over the world hold an Al Quds Conference on the 21st of Ramadhan every year, as announced by the spiritual leader of the Islamic Revolution, to mark both solidarity with Palestine as well as to renew their commitment to free Palestine from Israeli occupation. 

This year however, the conference was organised jointly by the Iranian Embassy in Islamabad and the National Press Club of Islamabad. Senator Talha represented the Pakistani State. 

The Iranian ambassador to Islamabad urged the Muslims to unite themselves against oppression, while Iran's cultural counsellor Agha Khazai reiterated Iran's commitment to stand for Palestine. 

I was invited to speak both on Al Quds and Jammu Kashmir. Thanking Iran and all the other speakers who spoke for Kashmir as well, I have made the following recommendations to the ambassador, in writing: 

1) The OIC must review its policies and relationships among its members. Why its counterparts like the European Union, African Union and Russian Federation as well as NATO have progressed; promoted and consolidated themselves but not the OIC? 

2) The Turkiye Government under Recep Tayyip Erdogan had announced a zero conflict policy with its neighbours over a decade back - but instead - all the Muslim states in the region are in conflict with each other. We urge an immediate review of the situation. 

3) Palestine, Jammu Kashmir, Libya and Syria are bleeding; while Iran and Afghanistan are suffering from unfair and unjustifiable economic sanctions. 

4) The Kurd and Yemen issue should be negotiated too for a lasting peaceful solution or it will always be exploited by imperialistic powers. 

There are two major causes of all of the above problems, in my opinion:

First, prevalent disunity and confrontation between Muslim states. Second, our acceptance of an undemocratic, discriminatory, monopolistic and manipulative United Nations Security Council; that has five permanent members using the UN to their advantage. 

In order to bring about a positive change in the Muslim World and protection, we recommend an active role of the OIC, a joint Islamic think tank, a separate independent Islamic Court of Justice, a joint defence force and a common Islamic economic market. This may sound difficult but it has to be initiated if the resources of the Muslim World and its human rights are to be protected from the forces of exploitation. 

We hope Your Excellency will support our recommendations and kindly forward them to your  government. 

Wassalam

Abdul Quayyum Raja
Founding Chairman
Centre for Jammu Kashmir Public Diplomacy

....

More important than the news item itself, its encouraging to see the global news agency Reuters in action in AJK. We hope it maintains its alertness for the rocky road to freedom ahead:
 

....

Wednesday, 4 May 2022

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 124 of 2022

1537hrs:

Break day 10 of district (Kotli) wide tour

Eid festivities have yet to cease.

....

The following is a perfect example of the United Kingdom's 'pick and choose' policy when it comes to international diplomacy and advocating democracy abroad. Is it not ironic that Nusrat Ghani MP - whose family originates from AJK - has probably never had anything to say publicly - about the Pakistani occupation of this territory - that was designed and implemented by British colonialism - but is keen on advocating for the Uyghurs under Chinese occupation. Notwithstanding our point, the latter has its own merits of course and the territory in question is also adjacent to our country viz. JKA:

....

Wednesday, 16 February 2022

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 47 of 2022

0917hrs:

Day 28 at Martyr's Square Kotli


Another not so random click at the castle of strategic aspirations:


......

Students of Kotli stand and protest in solidarity with their brothers and sisters at AJK University in Muzaffarabad, who were beaten black and blue by AJK police. 

Why? 

Because they were peacefully protesting for rights that students throughout the world usually do not need to protest over.

The attitude of the AJK government to demands for basic rights by any citizen(s) of any shape or kind?

Beat them up and force them them to re-think the reality in which they live.

Almost zero governance, as declared by AJK PUBLIC AGENCY 


They also took this opportunity to show solidarity with me:


.......

Media attention has increased markedly in the past few days and that has got to be a positive development. Here's another example:


.......

Journalist Fazal ur Rehman of Smaahni is at full steam and on the ball:






......

A circular was sent out in the evening to 10 'nationalist' political parties of AJK in Urdu:

کوٹلی شہید چوک ۔۔

ملک وسیم اور ان کی فیملی کے ایشو پر کل شام 6 بجے شہید چوک کوٹلی میں سب ہم وطنوں کوبشمول جتنے بھی سیاسی پارٹیوں کے عہدےداران ہیں ۔ایک منفرد اجتماع جس میں آپ کی شرکت پوری قوم کے لیے ایک پیشرفت ہوگی ۔۔۔

Here's the Roman Urdu version of the invite:

Malik Waseem aur family ke issue par kal 6 bajey shaam ko Shaheed Chowk Kotli me daawat hay sab humwatano ko, baashamool jitney bhi political party audidaar han....Aik munfarid ijtima hoga aur aap ki shirkat puri quom ke liye aik peshraft hogi...

Party representatives invited:

1) JKLF - T (Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front - Toqeer faction)
2) JKLF - H (Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front - Haq Nawaz faction)
3) JKNAP (Jammu Kashmir National Awami Party)
4) JKNSF - Azad (Jammu Kashmir National Student's Federation - free faction)
5) KFM (Kashmir Freedom Movement)
6) JKSLF - Azad (Jammu Kashmir Student's Liberation Front - free faction)
7) UKPNP (United Kashmir People's National Party)
8) JKNEP (Jammu Kashmir National Equality Party)
9) KNP (Kashmir National Party)
10) JKLF - S (Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front - Sagheer faction)

........

Sunday, 3 October 2021

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 276 of 2021

2256hrs:

A good conversation this evening:


For those of you who prefer Youtube:


......

Wednesday, 15 September 2021

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 258 of 2021

2259hrs:

Travel continues........putting the past few days into perspective.....reviewing the experience....the biggest challenge by far is the competing attitudes of my own people. Most mean well but tend to operate in circles.....result: little forward movement....and if there is, it is followed by many steps back. It's a challenge I relish though despite everything.

.....

Today was yet another busy day. Some of my journalist friends had insisted that I should conduct a press conference at Central Press Club Muzaffarabad, not least to begin mainstream interaction despite contesting narratives (viz. the Pakistani nationalist narrative versus the internal narrative of AJK). 


Here's the video footage:


Earlier in the day I had paid a visit to the High Court of AJK as well as the Department of Tourism & Archeology where I met DG (Director General) Irshaad Peerzada to discuss the latest events in and in reference to Sharda:


Here are the video updates given outside the building:


....

Saturday, 30 November 2019

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 334 of 2019

1135hrs:

Another day in court where arguments for the defence and prosecution were to be heard. However, the Qazi (judge in Islamic terminology) despite giving a date yesterday - for today - was absent. We will now return to his court on the 3rd of December (this coming Tuesday).

As reiterated on Facebook:




........

We are continuing to receive coverage in the local Urdu press. In more than one publication now:



Daily Kashmir Uzma - Muzaffarabad (Urdu)


Back Page (1 of 2)


Back Page (2 of 2)


Page 3 Section 19

The Daily Siyasat also gave us coverage:



Daily Siyasat - Muzaffarabad (Urdu)


Front Page

These are positive indications from a public interest point of view. One, most local newspapers concentrate on acting as commercial advertising space for the Pakistani narrative, local politicians and for overall bolstering of perceptions for the imposed governance set-up, laced with rhetoric. Secondly, they charge people for publicity as advertising revenue doesn't quite fulfil the needs of the employees or the owners of the newspapers. The structure is such that media is sucked into the black hole of power and corruption. 


Giving coverage to public interest and on their own initiative - without payment or enticement - can be considered to be a positive step for civil society in AJK. Especially, if it remains consistent and sustains itself.


.....


With the deluge of information and analysis on virtually every topic of consequence available via social media on a daily basis, one has to fend off the temptation to delve into matters that have no direct impact on the State of Jammu & Kashmir's (re)formation project. However, the following is one such video that I felt compelled to watch for its bold initiative in examining China's role in East Turkistan or what China insists on calling 'Xinjiang'. What our people in the various parts of J & K endure is still on a scale a few notches below what China is evidently doing there but the pattern of repression is very similar:



Now, I would like to point out that we (the aspiring citizens of J & K) have bones to pick with each of the 5 following countries that are preventing us from naturally progressing as a nation State viz. China, India, Pakistan, UK and USA. We maintain our aspiration to remain neutral in principle. We are not highlighting China's crimes against humanity because we want to show USA in a good light etc. 

We are concerned that the country with which we share our longest border; remains engaged in forcibly integrating those areas which are geographically on its periphery and are not part of the mainstream Han Chinese population viz. Tibet and Xinjiang. As these areas are conterminous with us and thus have huge stakes for China especially given their keenness to expand their OBOR (One Belt One Road) project through our territory (via GB in particular), compounded by the fact that China has no democratic tradition puts a very serious dilemma in front of us. 

While we are engaged in avenues of activating global civil society in mature democracies such as UK and USA and while India and Pakistan are still struggling with nationhood in their own realms we see no such avenue to address China's stance on Jammu & Kashmir.

.......     

Monday, 5 August 2019

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 217 of 2019

1514hrs:

So, the whole of Jammu & Kashmir is mired in total uncertainty at the moment.

This may be a time when most people are anxious or even helpless but this brings opportunity to the internal narrative on an unprecedented scale.

The following tweet reminds me of the late, great K. H. Khursheed: 




Here's a short documented video profile of (K for) Khursheed (H for) Hassan Khursheed:





Please note that there is a minor error in the narration at 01:30 whereby in fact Ram Chander Kak was succeeded by General Janak Singh as prime minister of J & K before Mehr Chand Mahajan in turn replaced him. Mr. Mahajan had also been instrumental earlier in August (1947) as an assistant to the British lawyer Cyril Radcliffe in demarcating the new post-partition boundary/border in Punjab.

......

An 'Internal Political Process - AJK'

I've been very clear about what Pakistan needs to do, at least since 2012. Unilateral de-militarisation beginning from Tehsil (sub-division) Khuiratta in district Kotli, Mirpur (division of AJK) which we consider a part of Jammu region (the J in J & K).  

Here's a reminder given in this interview (in Urdu) at Khuiratta in 2016:




Once the defence, security and other concerning matters are stabilised in an alternative framework, driven by local civil society in AJK and concurred by the AJK government, including liaison with the international community and regional order; then India can be asked to vacate a similar sized tehsil in the Valley of Kashmir, where conflict has been most intense (apart from the LOC). A phased military withdrawal in such a manner (tehsil by tehsil in the sequence of Pakistan followed by India - one by one) will automatically and simultaneously generate the conditions for an internal political process (throughout Jammu & Kashmir) to take shape.

What is an internal (J & K) political process?

It is being improvised via independent research conducted uninterrupted since 2005.


It has 4 major sequences. 2 of which have been conducted, 1 is currently in process and the final sequence will involve 29 elected members of the AJK legislative assembly; from constituencies in AJK and thus excluding the 20 other members, for reasons to be elaborated on below.



Sequence 1:


A pilot study or an initial foray at the deep end of action-oriented research, which involved open-ended questions on all matters of public significance in public forums, put to a diverse set of aspiring citizens in each major town/city of AJK and GB between 2009 and 2012. C. 50 civil society forums in total. This initial exercise enabled me to witness all levels of ambiguity in society while being exposed to all manner of narratives held by people in both territories. This not only helped me frame the questions for the next sequence (so that I could begin to quantify public opinion); it also made me understand that GB and the other divided territories of Jammu & Kashmir need local citizens within each territory to devise a similar internal democratic framework cum internal political process through civic engagement for reclaiming ownership of their respective territories.



Sequence 2:


A representative sample of public opinion randomly obtained from all 32 tehsils (subdivisions) of AJK, between 2011 and 2016. Read the following document for a detailed summary. It should also be noted that a lengthier academic version of the public opinion survey report will be ready for publication in a Western academic journal this winter (2019/2020):



  



Sequence 3:


Whereas the 10 question public opinion survey was random and involved a sample of 10,000 citizens of AJK, the next sequence is what I describe as the most difficult part of the 4 sequences and where the conflict of interest between what AJK should be compared to what it is, will be tested. 


In this sequence we narrow down to identifying 1,000 of the most significant/influential citizens of AJK. They remain representative like the public opinion sample above because they will also be weighted and distributed - according to the population of each tehsil. These 1,000 people can be of any background, ideology, sect or tribe or but the citizens of any given tehsil will have to identify them (rather than me) and develop a consensus between themselves of the final list of nominations. They can be politicians/political workers (excluding the current members of AJK's legislative assembly because they are relevant for the 4th and final sequence), businessmen, lawyers, spiritual leaders, academicians, activists, professionals in other arenas etc.


The above can include members of the AJK diaspora but they must have some exposure,  a regular stake within AJK and be familiar with how it functions. While the public opinion survey had 10 questions extrapolated from the forums conducted in sequence 1, sequence 3 will have 4 questions based on the 4 sections of that 10 question survey.


Namely:


1) National Question:


Q. Do you agree that AJK should be demilitarised gradually tehsil by tehsil, whereby after the first tehsil is vacated and an alternative security structure is in place and stabilised,  then the same request would be put to the Indian government to vacate a similar sized tehsil in the Valley of Kashmir, where the conflict between both countries has been most intense since 1947?


Yes  / No / Don't know (which may include comments or remarks)


Note: My own calculation of the appropriate tehsil to be first to demilitarise is Khuiratta, for a range of reasons. One is that it is in the Jammu region (via Mirpur division) and thus far only Poonch and Muzaffarabad have had limited routes opened, whereby the most divided as well as most populated region is Jammu. Secondly, the Indians have a very clear military advantage in Khuiratta as the whole Valley (Wadi e Banaah) is directly beneath them, thus the Pakistanis have very limited deterrence value here, if at all. 


As for the alternative security arrangements, these should include 2 components viz. 1 local and one international. The local component should be a combination of our citizens currently employed by the Pakistan army, who would be transferred here (under a local command and control structure, which also entails that the IG would have to be a local citizen and special branch/intelligence functions in AJK would also be answerable within rather than to Pakistani institutions) and a vetted list of those citizens who have been trained in the past and who now remain largely unemployed or working in miscellaneous security positions etc. The international component could be a stronger number of UN forces to patrol between Indian and local AJK positions. My own opinion is that rather than UN forces, the UK should take responsibility for interim security measures here (during the demilitarisation phase), as not only did they facilitate the entry of Indian and Pakistani forces in 1947, they are also the creators of the ceasefire line cum LOC and no force in the world is more familiar with the region. 


2) Governance - Public Policy (Constitution/al matters):


Q: Do you agree that in the modern age of communications technology, having a correct (real-time) database of your population and its aggregate skill set is the first step to effective governance in AJK?


Yes  / No / Don't know (which may include comments or remarks)


Note: There are obviously a whole range of things that could be included to improve governance in AJK. For example, having our own educational curriculum is also a must, saving our forests, managing our water and there is a long list to follow. However, as human capital is always going to be your most precious asset, being able to measure its number and what skills it possesses will enable both the government and the people to reflect that information in consulting and designing public policy. This will also give us an accurate figure of our diaspora and where they have spread out to. We can then think about 'brain gain' as opposed to suffering from decades and centuries of 'brain drain'.


The census data gathered in the decades pre-1947 should provide a sound basis of determining those who qualify as state subjects and thus unnecessary external influence can be minimised. Once you are clear about your assets and income possibilities, you can then drive your country forward and develop all other vital government institutions needed for progress and competing with the rest of the world.


Also remember, there can be no genuine rai shumari (plebiscite, referendum, public opinion) without genuine (localised) mardum shumari (population census data in real time). On this note, it should be pointed out there are 3 conventional means of measuring public opinion in a democratic framework:


i) Periodic Elections - They don't work here because of overbearing military presence & structural reliance on Pakistan's federation. Merit, transparency and accountability among other features of democracy are also almost non-existent here.
ii) Plebiscite/Referendum - Promised since Mountbatten's response to Maharajah Hari Singh's request for military assistance to quell Pakistani invasion in October 1947 but not forthcoming at this stage. It would necessitate military withdrawal in any case ref. Question 1 above.
iii) Public opinion polls/survey - This was the only practical means available to us to measure public opinion and even this had attempted obstruction from Pakistan's clandestine agencies. In any case, it has provided us a reference to launch an internal political process.

3) The economy:


Q: Should AJK take responsibility for all matters of fiscal and monetary significance in AJK, including taking responsibility for all direct as well as indirect taxation?


Yes  / No / Don't know (which may include comments or remarks)


Note: I think this question should be self-explanatory but one should now be able to notice that each of the 4 sequences as well as each of the 4 questions logically follow each other. For example, we can't have control over taxation (no.3) if we don't have control over population data (no,2) and likewise we can't have control over population data if we remain occupied. In fact, the current Pakistani government's representative and a form of foreign policy think-tank Shireen Mazari said in October last year in a presentation to Strategic Studies Institute Islamabad (where she was director when I met her in 2005), that if we think we can talk peace or move towards conflict resolution without demilitarisation, we are only fooling ourselves. I am of course paraphrasing her. You can read the text or listen to her speech at the following link.   


For almost 72 years we have been deprived of the most fundamental benefit of taxation viz. representation in a political economy. If our political representatives do not have direct access to a public treasury generated from citizen's taxes, then instead of representing us they will have no choice but to represent the interests of those controlling the public's treasury. Hence...

4) Society (regaining religious/cultural equilibrium):


Q: Should the AJK government and civil society actively engage to facilitate the renovation and revitalisation of Mandirs, Gurdwaras and other places of historic or cultural significance?


Yes  / No / Don't know (which may include comments or remarks)


Note: So, this would be the icing on the cake of a resurgent AJK. Clear and unambiguous about its status and taking all aspects of its past into the future. Our legitimacy as inheritors of AJK depends on us reversing the policy of our forefathers to kill, convert or drive away our non Muslim community in 1947. This would be the epitome of 'soft power', the most authentic fulfillment of Ownership-Building Measures (OBMs) and a clear message that (the) white (flag) reflects not only peace but a will to design our future, beginning with a clean slate - no pre-conceived inhumane biases - dependent on the inclusiveness of all sections of our society.  


This facility should be part of a mutual cross LOC process, whereby the Muslims on this side should also be equally facilitated to visit shrines, other places of worship and heritage on the other side in equal measure, using a cross LOC permit or other internal 'riyasatee' identification document.

...

Moving on, the 1,000 influential stakeholders would be divided into tehsils in the following manner:


Division



Sample
Per Cent
Mirpur
405
41%
Muzaffarabad
266
27%
Poonch
329
33%




District



Sample
Per Cent
Bagh
90
9%
Bhimber
109
11%
Hattian Bala
60
6%
Haveli
36
4%
Kotli
194
19%
Mirpur
102
10%
Muzaffarabad
160
16%
Neelam
46
5%
Poonch
130
13%
Sudhnoti
73
7%


Tehsil (sub-division)



Sample
Per Cent

Abbaspur
19
2%
Athmaqam
30
3%
Bagh
35
4%
Baloch
18
2%
Barnaala
36
3%
Bhimber
42
4%
Charoi
16
2%
Chikaar
10
1%
Dadyaal
31
3%
Darlya Jattan
14
1%
Dheerkot
39
4%
Hajeera
47
5%
Harigel
16
2%
Hattian Bala
38
4%
Haveli
18
2%
Khuiratta
22
3%
Khursheedabad
7
1%
Kotli
76
7%
Leepa
12
1%
Mirpur
71
7%
Mong
8
1%
Mumtazabad
11
1%
Muzaffarabad
111
11%
Nikyaal
16
2%
Palandri
32
3%
Pateeka
49
5%
Rawalakot
55
6%
Samaahni
31
3%
Sehnsa
50
5%
Sharda
16
2%
Thorar
9
1%
Trarkhel
15
1%
Notes: (3)

1) Percentages have been rounded off to the nearest whole number.


2) To balance the weightage between categories, Muzaffarabad Division has been favoured over Mirpur. 



3) The following adjustments in weightage have been made to make up for minor skewness during fieldwork for Citizen Public Opinion Survey - AJK:


District
Sub-division
Added (+)
Bhimber
Barnaala
4
Kotli
Kotli
3
Neelam
Athmaqam
1
Sudhnoti
Palandri
4
Sudhnoti
Trarkhel
2





Taken Away (-)
Bhimber
Samaahni
-4
Kotli
Khuiratta
-3
Neelam
Sharda
-1
Sudhnoti
Baloch
-6


If a majority of 501 or more of these influential citizens decide to agree (Yes) to the 4 items on the agenda, for advancing an internal political process then we can move to the final and (relatively less difficult) 4th sequence:


Sequence 4:


To put the very same 4 items to 29 MLAs representing the 29 constituencies in AJK, where there has been uninterrupted elections since 1985. They count for 50% weightage in this internal political process as the vast majority of them have firm grounding in their constituencies and are looked up to for leadership by an unignorable amount of people within them. The other 20 members who comprise of 12 people elected from various 'migrant' constituencies in Pakistan, 5 women, a technocrat, an aalim/mashaikh (Islamic scholar) and an overseas 'Kashmiri' representative have barely any democratic justification while the 12 'migrants' (the progeny of those who had to flee from Indian-controlled J & K in 1947 onwards, who have settled in various parts of Pakistan and enjoy the vote in both entities viz. AJK and Pakistan) are hardly in touch with the realities of AJK.

The remaining 50% weightage in this internal political process remains with the people/civil society/public and can be measured using such tools as the 3 sequences prior to this final sequence. If at least 15 of the 29 MLAs agree to the 4 points on the agenda, then as a political entity described as AJK, we can legislate on them in the very assembly that has to date looked up to the State of Pakistan for direction, guidance, finance and influence.


The very assembly that ratified the Interim Act in 1974 is the very assembly that can ultimately abandon it. The only difference is that hitherto the assembly members took their cue from the Pakistani State and have tried to obtain concessions over authority from them, with very limited success if at all. This time the cue would come from an internal political process, which would provide enough cover and a shield for our politicians, to minimise 'blowback' from the Pakistani State.


Throughout these 14 years of independent research thus far, it gradually became apparent that mobilising the public here on the basis of a political ideology, party,class, tribe, region, religion, sect or any other category which occupiers have used as divisive tools for centuries, would not bear fruit. Not least because they all overlap the concept of a nation-State at some point and are likely to hinder the building of an internal consensus, under one pretext or the other. 


This does not by any means mean that the owners of these categories are not owners of the territory we have all inherited. Indeed, many of these categories may come in use to mobilise public opinion on this internal political process. Furthermore, many people from these categories will also feature among those 1,000 significant citizens. 

Perhaps an even more prominent factor in the context of how society operates in AJK is, how does one efficiently navigate around the chicanery of Pakistan's clandestine agencies? None of the categories described above have been able to persist on their own. If your work is as diverse as the society you operate in, then you are likely to be effective. If you treat every citizen as an asset and accumulate public interest in tiny elements over years of practice on the ground; then distribute that strength throughout society and the polity you exist in, subsequently deriving decisions in favour of public interest becomes a habit.


I do recognise that many questions may (and should) flow from all that I've written but please remember that I started off as one lost soul in 2005 but to date we have managed to accumulate the direct help (finance - cash & in kind - logistics, protection) from more than 35,000 aspiring citizens at home and in our diaspora. Those who have indirectly helped number many more. This assistance in promoting public interest is most certainly a collective effort but not one that can be conventionally measured viz. political party strength, organisational capability, quality of cadre, large finance or even international backing. However, it is inclusive (of all sections of society and departments in government); spontaneous, collective, flexible, agile and most importantly rooted in the needs, aspirations and existing capacity of the people. The very aspiring citizens who also happen to be the very marginalised inheritors of this territory, whose reference has been quoted by all and sundry, for perceived legitimacy.    


If we - in AJK - successfully proceed beyond sequence 4, then a ready made model (with room for local variation of course) could be adopted by each of the seemingly disparate territories of the erstwhile State of Jammu & Kashmir. 


If we cannot convince our co-citizens - including our apparent political representatives - to mobilise around public interest, there is little honour in taking our case to the world, to seek that elusive justice that we deny to each other? 


Taking this internal political process forward:

I have been trying to address Tehsil/District Bar Associations and Government/Private Graduate/Post-Graduate Colleges/Universities throughout AJK for the past year or so but with very limited success thus far. However, I wouldn't be disheartened because each sequence on this journey has undergone many hurdles. A process of increasing the confidence of our citizens as a collective political entity is ongoing whilst simultaneously softening the barriers put up by our neighbour.

Our co-citizens are urged to take a practical role in this process, which essentially belongs to all of us. At the first instance, most of us can nominate who they think would qualify as an influential/significant citizen in their respective tehsil.

The names could be emailed at: sahaafi@gmail.com or sent via other social media platforms linked on the right pane of this blog.   

For further background reading:

1) 
Please read up on what is commonly described as K. H. Khursheed Sb's formula, which was presented to the Pakistani State while he was president of AJK, at the end of September 1962, upon the formation of his party viz. Jammu Kashmir Liberation League (JKLL). Wherein Muzaffarabad should be recognised as the rebellious and representative dejure government of the erstwhile princely State of J & K. Further, that initially Pakistan should recognise it and then ask friendly countries to recognise it too. 

The intended purpose was to get the actual stakeholders of the J & K Question (Kashmir dispute) viz. the people of the territory to represent their own case globally, in a bid to obtain self-determination and avoid being further marginalised in a bilateral territorial dispute. At the time, it is understood that 28 countries - including China - had given their indication of consent to recognise this government. 

Equally, it is important to understand the strife he had to go through for his sincere endeavours and how & why he was foiled.

2) Please also read up on Colin Irwin - a Research Fellow in the Department of Politics at the University of Liverpool in the UK - and in particular the following 2 publications of his:

i) The Northern Ireland ‘Peace Polls’
ii) The People's Peace - Pax Populi Pax Dei

3) The following needs to be read as background to fully grasp what I am proposing as an internal political process:




End of document......'Internal Political Process - AJK' 

.......

On this explosive day in Jammu & Kashmir the defense attachés of China, Britain, France, Russia, Germany and other countries paid a visit to our side of the Line of Control. As reported by Pakistan Today

It should be remembered that on February the 23rd last year (2018) a similar 'excursion' of defense attachés visited the Poonch sector of the LOC on this side too. On that occasion the countries involved were US, UK, France, China, Turkey and Indonesia. As reported by Radio Pakistan

Courtesy: Radio Pakistan
Courtesy: Radio Pakistan

So, it could be extrapolated that all 5 permanent members of the UN Security Council remain interested in what happens in this territory. Each visit has involved 4 out of 5 with Russia on this occasion and America on the previous such visit. Of course, the UK or Britain was involved in both visits. Thus, their input on the future of J & K remains critical despite their protestations to the contrary. 

......

A selection of excerpts from a spat between India media and the government of India whereby the UK makes a welcome 'intervention':


" The Wire has also confirmed that Jaishankar did write to Javadekar that the two sponsor governments were told through diplomatic channels that it was “unacceptable and unfortunate” that a platform had been provided to make “unfounded remarks” against India.


The UK government doesn’t seem to agree – at least as per the remarks of the high commissioner to India, Dominic Asquith.


When asked at a recent interaction about the Indian government’s protest, he stated that it was agreed by all those who participated that media freedom event was a “vital part of international responsibility”.


Asquith noted that a “range of views were, of course, expressed at the conference as you would expect”.


He added, “It is a forum for exchanging views, not a forum to suppress views”.


The British envoy also went on to state that it was not surprising that a presentation made by a journalist would not fall in line with narratives of governments.


“I can say that not just in that case, the views expressed in the conference, as you would expect professional journalists are not always aligned to some of the governments. So, that’s what freedom of media means. In the context of that conference, the chairman of Prasar Bharati had space made for him by the chairman (of the session) to respond to the comments made…and we have of course listened to him,” he said.


.........Vinod Jose told The Wire that he welcomed the UK high commissioner’s statement. “If the UK government’s India envoy did not respond to the Indian government’s criticism positively, he was echoing the sentiment expressed by the global community in London last month. As an Indian, I am ashamed that the Indian government had to be reminded of the definition of a professional journalist – someone who is not always aligned to the government,” he said.


......The senior Indian journalist was highly critical of India’s move to formally object to his presence with foreign governments.


“Minister Jaishankar’s response is a glowing validation of why a Global Conference for Media Freedom was needed in the first place: because governments and vested interests are throttling the press world over, and we need collective local and global efforts to resist such suppression to safeguard whatever little we have built since World War II in terms of value systems and democracy,” said Jose.


He felt that that “whoever advised a career-bureaucrat-turned-minister to write such a letter is painting the Indian Foreign Service and Indian diplomacy in poor light”.


....He also observed that the 20th century had witnessed the choice made by diplomats, ministers, journalists and jurists to be on the side of truth and justice, freedom of press and rule of law, while others chose authoritarian governments, control of media and arbitrary decision-making. “I don’t think the 21st century will be very different either. Individuals and governments are taking positions, and I hope individuals and governments still slipping on the wrong side will calibrate their positions to be on the right side of history,” said the senior journalist.

"

End of selected excerpts from:


After India Protests, UK Says Journalists' Views Can’t Always Be Aligned With Govt's



Courtesy: thewire.in

My comment:


Now, this is what the British excel at. However, it's a pity they don't utilise such diplomacy in the avoidable dispute referred to once, as the 'Jammu & Kashmir Question'.


.....

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 321 of 2026

1604hrs: On Day 166 uncertainty still looms heavily on our people. We know the past history of the Pakistani State and it isn't illustri...