Visitors

Showing posts with label Quayyum Raja. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Quayyum Raja. Show all posts

Tuesday, 31 March 2026

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 90 of 2026

0307hrs:

Another damn false start as the rain continues into the 2nd morning with intermittent spells of sunshine during the day. I will not let this sleeping routine become my Achilles heel. 

....

#NoElection2026AJK

Solution:
#InternalPublicContract2026AJK 

Opinion;
Safeer Abbasi - #JhelumValleyAJK


Addressing the people (Riyasati Baashindey) from:
#Lakhanpur2Gilgit
#Lakhanpur 
#Gilgit
#JKA 

JKA PUBLIC AGENCY Note: #E174831032026

....

A guest post is in order at times and the following notes of caution are provided by Quayyum Raja this morning. They were initially published as an article on RAZ TV:

Quayyum Raja with The Hague's Peace Palace in the background

Vitriolic Political Language Versus International Diplomacy: Lessons for the Kashmir Conflict

Political language has always been a powerful tool, capable of shaping public opinion, mobilizing populations, and defining national identity. In recent years, however, the rise of vitriolic political language—characterized by hostility, absolutism, and emotionally charged rhetoric—has increasingly contrasted with the measured and strategic discourse required in international diplomacy. This tension is particularly relevant in the context of the Kashmir conflict, where competing narratives, strong sentiments, and geopolitical realities intersect.

Vitriolic political language often emerges in highly polarized environments. Within Kashmir, pro-independence groups frequently employ rhetoric that is deeply rooted in local grievances, historical injustices, and identity-based mobilization. Such language can be effective in galvanizing local support, reinforcing solidarity, and sustaining resistance movements. However, it also tends to frame the conflict in uncompromising terms, leaving little room for dialogue, negotiation, or pragmatic compromise.

While this locally focused rhetoric may resonate strongly with the population on the ground, it can inadvertently limit the broader effectiveness of the movement. International diplomacy operates on a different set of principles—one that prioritizes strategic communication, credibility, and engagement with multiple stakeholders, including states, international organizations, and global public opinion. Language that is overly confrontational or rigid may fail to gain traction beyond local audiences and can reduce the willingness of external actors to engage constructively.

A lasting solution to the Kashmir conflict requires not only internal cohesion but also meaningful international engagement. Pro-independence groups, therefore, face the challenge of recalibrating their communication strategies. Rather than relying solely on emotionally charged or absolutist rhetoric, there is a need to adopt a more balanced approach—one that retains legitimacy among local populations while also appealing to international norms such as human rights, self-determination, and peaceful conflict resolution.

This does not imply abandoning core demands or diluting political aspirations. Instead, it involves reframing these aspirations in a way that is accessible and persuasive to a global audience. For instance, emphasizing legal frameworks, humanitarian concerns, and alignment with international law can strengthen the credibility of the movement. Similarly, engaging in diplomatic channels, building alliances, and maintaining consistency in messaging can enhance its legitimacy on the world stage.

Moreover, the use of less vitriolic and more strategic language can open pathways for dialogue. International actors are more likely to support initiatives that demonstrate a willingness to engage constructively rather than escalate tensions. By moderating rhetoric and incorporating diplomatic sensibilities, pro-independence groups can position themselves as credible stakeholders in any future negotiations.

Ultimately, the contrast between vitriolic political language and international diplomacy highlights a critical dilemma in the Kashmir conflict: the need to balance local mobilization with global engagement. While strong rhetoric may sustain internal momentum, it is insufficient on its own to achieve a practical and lasting resolution. Success depends on the ability to bridge these two spheres—maintaining the trust and support of the local population while simultaneously appealing to the international community.

In an increasingly interconnected world, conflicts are rarely resolved in isolation. The Kashmir issue is no exception. A realistic and sustainable solution will require not only political will but also a strategic shift in communication—one that harmonizes domestic narratives with the expectations and mechanisms of international diplomacy.

....

Dadyaal Declaration 
Jammu Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee JK JAAC

Copied ad verbatim from comment section of Shams Rehman's Facebook post as linked at end....

**Meeting held on 30–31 March, 2026 
In the spirit of standing up to unjust rulers, the Jammu Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee issues the following declaration:
### *1. Elections and Reforms*
The Core Committee demands *constitutional and electoral reforms* to ensure that upcoming elections in Azad Jammu & Kashmir are *transparent, fair, credible, and impartial*, so that people can genuinely exercise their right to vote.
After consultations with Action Committees across all three divisions and broad public opinion, the Committee has concluded that:
* Holding elections *without resolving the issue of the 12 disputed refugee seats* (allocated in the name of refugees residing in Pakistan),
* And *without implementing agreed reforms*,
would amount to a *betrayal of the people of Azad Kashmir*.
The Committee makes it clear:
* We are *not against democracy or elections*,
* But we *reject any electoral process* that allows these *12 controversial seats to distort the public mandate*.
*Key demands:*
* Abolition of the 12 disputed refugee seats before elections
* Full implementation of the *4 October 2025 agreement*
* Enforcement of the *Charter of Demands*
* End to *unjust privileges of the ruling elite before elections*
The Committee also calls for:
* Formation of an *independent Election Commission*
* Fair constituency delimitation based on population
* Broad-based consultation with all stakeholders, including the Action Committee
A detailed *Charter of Demands on electoral reforms* has already been prepared.
### *2. Deadline and Protest Plan*
Despite serious reservations, the Committee will continue negotiations with the *Monitoring & Implementation Committee*.
A firm *deadline of 31 May 2026* has been given to the government to:
* Implement the Charter of Demands
* Honour the 4 October 2025 agreement
* Carry out electoral reforms
After this date, the Committee will *no longer consider itself bound* by previous understandings, given repeated violations by the authorities.
If demands are not met:
* A *historic long march* towards the Legislative Assembly in Muzaffarabad will take place on *9 June 2026*
* The march will begin from *Bhimber–Mirpur*
* A *sit-in (dharna)* will continue outside the Assembly for an indefinite period
* A *region-wide shutdown (lockdown/strike)* will also be enforced
### *3. Public Mobilisation*
The Committee calls on the public to:
* *Prepare immediately* for the movement
* Store *at least one month’s essential supplies*
* Activate *ward-level committees* across all districts
A mass mobilisation campaign will begin, including:
* Public outreach drives
* Seminars and conferences
* Advocacy for *right to ownership and right to governance*
Overseas Kashmiris are urged to *play an active role*, as they have in the past.
Media, both local and international, are called upon to *expose government violations of commitments* made to the people.
### *4. Political and Legal Concerns*
The Committee demands:
* Immediate release of all arrested leaders and workers, including those from Gilgit-Baltistan
It strongly condemns:
* The FIR registered by NCCIA against Core Committee member *Shaukat Nawaz Mir, who had merely demanded action against those responsible for the **29 September firing on peaceful civilians*, which resulted in deaths and injuries
The Committee also highlights:
* The contradiction where a self-proclaimed Hurriyat leader admits meeting Indian intelligence officials,
* While Kashmiri journalist *Sohrab Barkat* has been imprisoned for over 100 days simply for interviewing a political worker
This, the Committee states, raises *serious questions about justice and political bias*.
### *5. Education and Resource Issues*
Regarding education reforms:
* The demand for *two new education boards* (for Muzaffarabad and Poonch divisions) has been accepted in principle and notified
However, the Committee warns:
* The government appears to be planning to *fund these boards by transferring assets from the Mirpur Board*,
* Which it calls a *dangerous and divisive move* that could create regional tensions
The Committee *rejects this approach* and warns of strong resistance.
6. Financial Transparency Warning*
The government is warned that:
* The *10 billion rupees grant to the electricity department*, as agreed on 4 October 2025,
* Must be used *transparently and on merit*
Any attempt to use these funds as *political patronage or bribery* will be resisted through public protest.

End....


Feedback on social media:


English translation:

Awami Action Committee has made a beautiful decision imbued with ingenuity.

End of translation..

....

Public Finance Update:

Number of co-citizens who have paid their share (over 20 years): 
16
Number of co-citizens who have paid a portion to date, since direct public funding began in 2012:
213
Number of co-citizens who have promised to pay:
86
Number of co-citizens I have directly contacted since the 9th of October 2025 (of total 5,000):
590

Cash in Hand: 55,780
Cash Deposits: 265,757
Immediate Debts: 0

....  

Friday, 9 January 2026

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 9 of 2026

1222hrs:

Compared to the previous 2 nights, a slight improvement was made in that I got to sleep at c. 0100hrs. I did awake at 0800hrs but didn't actually get up till 1000hrs, 7 hours later than my ideal and aspired for time to wake up. 

Now that I'm returning home today, I hope I can resume working on setting that ideal routine in place.

....


The following audio is an AI powered (generated) review by Academia.edu , of one of our most significant pieces of independent research, during this 2 decades old journey from 'Subject to Citizen':
  

The survey report itself, namely 'Citizen Public Opinion Survey Report 1.0 AJK (Azad Jammu & Kashmir' can be accessed and discussed on Academia.edu at this link.

The following is an exact transcription of the audio above:

Woman:
The paper we are into today is ..um.. Citizen Public Opinion Survey Report 1.0 – AJK (Azad Jammu & Kashmir) by Tanveer Ahmed

Quite a mouthful huh?

Man:
Definitely a mouthful but also ..I mean.. the title almost undersells how ambitious this project actually is.

It’s a 5 year effort. 

10,000 surveys across all 32 subdivisions of AJK 

I get tired just listing the numbers!

Woman:
Right!

And ..you know.. what drew me in right away was the core question this survey tackles.

Basically, what do the citizens of Azad Jammu & Kashmir – so often talked about but rarely heard from.

What do they actually want?

What do they think about identity? Governance? The economy and society?

Man:
Yeah.. And that question is significant because ..um.. I guess most of what we hear about Kashmir comes from politicians or the media or quote unquote experts right?

So.. Hearing from regular citizens especially in a zone with so much history and complexity just feels.. Like a breath of fresh air! 

Woman:
It really does!

And the paper doesn’t shy away from showing just how hard it was to even do research in AJK.

Like the author Tanveer Ahmed describes being detained ..actually.. Kidnapped! Twice! By security agencies for just.. ..well..trying to ask people questions..

That says a lot about the climate for public discourse.

Man:
Absolutely!

I mean.. If just running a survey takes that much risk, you realise how rare these kinds of insights actually are.

But.. Let’s get into some of those findings.

The numbers themselves are.. ..um..kind of striking!

Woman:
You mean ..like.. How 73% of respondents identify as Kashmiri first versus only 27% as Pakistani and just a tiny fraction ..basically nobody..as Indian?

Man:
That’s wild!

So much of the outside world frames AJK as a contest between India & Pakistan but for the people themselves, those aren’t the main identities at all!

Woman:
Yaah.. ..and..on the question about the integrity of the historic State: Jammu & Kashmir as it existed before 1947, 97% support that.

Which ..sort of..rebuffs the idea that borders as they stand make sense locally!

There is this yearning for wholeness I think.

Man:
And then.. On government & institutions only 8% rated the current structure as good, most said it was weak or bad. 

There is a dissatisfaction that comes through pretty clearly!

Woman:
Oh.. And then there’s this strong consensus that having a citizen-state contract ..like a social contract..basic accountability.. 98% said that’s important!

I mean.. People want to participate! They just aren’t being given ..uh.. The right conditions!

Man:
Totally!

I also noticed ..um.. There’s this practical bent to their economic aspirations. 

Lot’s of emphasis on opening trade routes and controlling resources.

It’s not ‘pie in the sky’ ideology. It’s ..Let’s get things moving so people can prosper.

Woman:
A side note:

I found the gender breakdown ..kind of.. Frustrating! 

Only 10% of the respondents were women!

But.. Given social norms there ..it’s.. Maybe more than you’d expect!

I dunno.. I always wish for more balance in these things.

Man:
Yeah.. But like ..you see..the constraints in real time.

It’s a conservative society ..so even reaching and talking honestly with women is its own challenge!

But it points to how even surveys can ..uh..reflect larger social issues.

Woman:
Speaking of challenges.. Can we just pause and marvel for a sec.. At the whole crowd-funding angle?

Citizens being surveyed were actually asked to contribute ..and almost two-thirds did, in money or kind. 

That’s wild!

Imagine if that was the case with ..I dunno.. Gallup?

Man:
(A loud) Huh!      

That’d be something!

Please Venmo us for your phone poll.

But it does build ..like.. This sense of ownership right?

People literally have skin in the game.

I guess.. ..in a way.. It makes the survey more.. democratic, if that’s not too grand a word?

Woman:
Yaah!

And it really goes back to Ahmed’s idea of Ownership-Building Measures as the next level beyond trust-building.

Get people invested. Maybe they care more about outcomes.

Man:
The thing this paper makes clear to me is that ..uh.. ..research like this.. Isn’t some final truth.

It’s messy. It’s influenced by who’s reachable, who’s willing to talk. All that.

But it does give us a window ..A..what..starting point?

Woman:
Exactly!

It’s not gospel but it’s something to chew on.

And for those of us on the outside, it’s a reminder that behind the headlines real people are grappling with tough questions which ..I mean..feels universal!

Whether you’re in AJK or anywhere else.

Man:
Couldn’t have said it better!

It’s like academic insights are invitations, not conclusions.

So.. Let’s keep the conversation open.

Woman:
Definitely!

Thanks for unpacking this one with me.

Man:
Always a pleasure.

....
(end of 5 (min) : 26 (sec) English audio transcription  
....       

It has become evident that I need to translate & transcribe this English audio into Urdu and then subsequently into Pahaari too, to get through to the maximum possible targeted audience.

Here's the Urdu (audio followed by the written word) translation and transcription (with context & local metaphors added for clarity & relevance):


:خاتون

1.0 آج ہم جس پیپر پر بات کر رہے ہیں وہ ہے۔۔ہمم۔۔سٹیزن پبلک اوپینین سروے رپورٹ۔

اے جے کے - آزاد جموں و کشمیر - از تنویر احمد 

کافی لمبا نام ہے، ہے نا؟

:مرد

بالکل لمبا، لیکن ساتھ ہی… میرا مطلب ہے…یہ عنوان تقریباً اس بات کو کم ہی ظاہر کرتا ہے کہ یہ منصوبہ حقیقت میں کتنا حوصلہ مند ہے۔

یہ ایک 5 سالہ کوشش ہے۔

آزاد جموں و کشمیر  کی اس وقت کے تمام 32 تحصیلو میں 10،000سرویز

کیے گئے۔ یعنی دس ہزار ہم وطنوں سے رائے لی گئی۔

!میں صرف نمبرز گنواتے ہوئے ہی تھک جاتا ہوں 

:خاتون

!صحیح

اور… آپ جانتے ہیں… جو چیز مجھے فوراً     اپنی طرف کھینچ لائی وہ بنیادی سوال تھا جو یہ سروے اٹھاتا ہے۔ 

— بنیادی طور پر، آزاد جموں و کشمیر کے شہری—جن کے بارے میں اکثر بات کی جاتی ہے مگر شاذ و نادر ہی ان کی بات سنی جاتی ہے

وہ اصل میں کیا چاہتے ہیں؟

وہ شناخت کے بارے میں کیا سوچتے ہیں؟  حکمرانی کے بارے میں؟    ممعیشت اور معاشرے کے بارے میں؟

:مرد

ہاں… اور یہ سوال اس لیے اہم ہے کیونکہ… امم…میرا خیال ہے کہ ہم کشمیر کے بارے میں جو کچھ سنتے ہیں وہ زیادہ تر سیاست دانوں یا میڈیا یا نام نہاد ماہرین سے آتا ہے، ٹھیک ہے؟

تو!… عام شہریوں سے سننا، خاص طور پر ایسے خطے میں جہاں اتنی تاریخ اور پیچیدگی ہے، بس…تازہ ہوا کے جھونکے جیسا محسوس ہوتا ہے۔ 

:خاتون

!واقعی ایسا ہی ہے

اور یہ پیپر اس بات سے نہیں گھبراتا کہ  آزاد جموں و کشمیرمیں تحقیق کرنا کتنا مشکل تھا۔

!مثلاً مصنف تنویر احمد بتاتے ہیں کہ انہیں حراست میں لیا گیا… دراصل… اغوا کیا گیا

!دو مرتبہ! سیکیورٹی ایجنسیوں کی طرف سےصرف… یعنی… لوگوں سے سوال پوچھنے کی کوشش کرنے پر

یہ عوامی مکالمے کے ماحول کے بارے میں بہت کچھ بتا رہا ہے۔

:مرد

!یقیناً

 میرا مطلب ہے… اگر صرف ایک سروے چلانا ہی اتنا خطرناک ہو، تو آپ کو احساس ہوتا ہے کہ اس قسم کی معلومات کتنی نایاب ہیں۔

لیکن… آئیے اب کچھ نتائج کی بات کرتے ہیں۔

!اعداد و شمار خود… امم… خاصے چونکا دینے والے ہیں 

:خاتون

آپ کا مطلب ہے… جیسے…کہ 73 فیصد جواب دہندگان خود کو سب سے پہلے کشمیری سمجھتے ہیں

جبکہ صرف 27 فیصد پاکستانی کے طور پر شناخت کرتے ہیں، اور ایک بہت ہی چھوٹا سا حصہ… تقریباً کوئی نہیں…

خود کو بھارتی کہتا ہے؟

:مرد

!یہ تو واقعی تہلکہ خیزہے

باہر کی دنیا آزاد جموں و کشمیر کو بھارت اور پاکستان کے درمیان مقابلے کے طور پر پیش کرتی ہے،مگر خود لوگوں کے لیے یہ شناختیں بالکل مرکزی نہیں ہیں

:خاتون

ہاں…اور تاریخی ریاست جموں و کشمیر—جیسی کہ وہ 1947 سے پہلے تھی—کی سالمیت کے سوال پر 97 فیصد اس کے حق میں ہیں۔

!جو… کسی حد تک… اس خیال کو رد کرتا ہے کہ موجودہ سرحدیں مقامی طور پر بامعنی ہیں

میرے خیال میں یہاں مکمل پن کی ایک خواہش موجود ہے۔

:مرد

اور پھر… حکومت اور اداروں کے بارے   میںصرف 8 فیصد نے موجودہ ڈھانچے کو اچھا قرار دیا، زیادہ تر نے اسے کمزور

یا برا کہا۔

!یہاں ایک بے اطمینانی ہے جو کافی واضح طور پر سامنے آتی ہے 

:خاتون

اوہ! اور پھر شہری و ریاست کے درمیان معاہدے پر مضبوط اتفاق رائے ہے…یعنی سماجی معاہدہ…بنیادی جواب دہی…98 

!فیصد نے کہا کہ یہ اہم ہے

میرا مطلب ہے… لوگ حصہ لینا چاہتے ہیں! بس انہیں… آہ…درست حالات نہیں دیے جا رہے۔

:مرد

!بالکل

 میں نے یہ بھی نوٹ کیا کہ… امم…ان کی معاشی خواہشات میں ایک عملی انداز ہے۔

تجارتی راستے کھولنے اور وسائل کے اختیار پر کافی زور دیا گیا ہے۔

یہ کوئی “خیالی نظریہ” نہیں ہے۔یہ ہے…چلو چیزوں کو حرکت میں لائیں تاکہ لوگ خوشحال ہوسکیں۔ 

:خاتون

:ایک ضمنی بات

!مجھے صنفی تقسیم… کچھ… مایوس کن لگی

!صرف 10 فیصد جواب دہندگان خواتین تھیں

!لیکن… وہاں کے سماجی اصولوں کو دیکھتے ہوئے…شاید یہ… توقع سے زیادہ ہی ہو

 مجھے نہیں معلوم…میں ہمیشہ چاہتی ہوں کہ ان چیزوں میں زیادہ توازن ہو۔

:مرد

ہاں… لیکن جیسے کہ… آپ دیکھ سکتی  ہیں…یہ پابندیاں حقیقی وقت میں نظر آتی ہیں۔

!یہ ایک قدامت پسند معاشرہ ہے…تو خواتین تک پہنچنا اور ان سے کھل کر بات کرنا خود ایک آزمائش ہے

لیکن یہ اس بات کی طرف اشارہ کرتا ہے کہ حتیٰ کہ سرویز بھی… آہ…بڑے سماجی مسائل کی عکاسی کرتے ہیں۔ 

:خاتون

آزمائشو کی بات کرتے ہوئے…کیا ہم ایک لمحے کے لیے رک کر اس اجتماعی فنڈنگ والے پہلو پر حیرت انگیز ہو سکتے ہیں؟

جن شہریوں کا سروے کیا گیا، ان سے مالی تعاون بھی مانگا گیا…اور تقریباً دو تہائی نے، رقم یا کسی اور شکل میں، تعاون کیا۔

!یہ تو کمال ہے

ذرا تصور کریں اگر… پتا نہیں… گیلپ ایسا کرے؟

:مرد

!۔۔(زور سے) ہُہ

! وہ تو کچھ اور ہی ہوگا

! براہِ کرم اپنے فون پول یعنی رائے درج کرتے ہوئے ہمیں ایزی پیسہ کریں

لیکن یہ… جیسے…ملکیت کا احساس پیدا کرتا ہے، ہے نا؟

لوگوں کا عملی طور پر اس میں حصہ ہوتا ہے۔

میرا خیال ہے…ایک طرح سے…یہ سروے کو زیادہ… جمہوری بنا دیتا ہے، اگر یہ لفظ زیادہ عظیم نہ ہو۔ 

:خاتون

!ہاں

 اور یہ واقعی تنویراحمد کے اس تصور کی طرف واپس جاتا ہے۔۔ملکیت سازی کے اقدامات

Ownership-Building Measures (OBMs)

۔۔ یعنی اعتماد سازی سے اگلا مرحلہ۔

لوگوں کو شامل کرو۔انہیں سرمایہ کاری کرنے دو۔شاید وہ نتائج کی زیادہ پرواہ کریں۔

:مرد

یہ پیپر میرے لیے جو بات واضح کرتا ہے وہ یہ ہے کہ… آہ…اس طرح کی تحقیق…کوئی آخری سچ نہیں ہوتی۔

سیاسی سماجی فضا بے ترتیب ہے ۔اس پر اثر پڑتا ہے کہ کون دستیاب تھا، کون بات کرنے پر آمادہ تھا۔یہ سب۔

لیکن یہ ہمیں ایک جھروکہ دیتا ہے…ایک… کیا…آغاز؟ 

:خاتون

!بالکل

یہ کوئی مقدس سچ نہیں مگر یہ سوچنے کے لیے کچھ ضرور دیتا ہے۔

اور ہم جیسے باہر بیٹھے لوگوں کے لیےیہ یاد دہانی ہے کہ سرخیوں کے پیچھے حقیقی لوگ ہیں جو مشکل سوالات سے دوچار ہیں جو… میرا مطلب ہے…عالمگیر محسوس ہوتے ہیں

چاہے آپ آزاد جموں و کشمیر میں ہوں یا کہیں اور۔

:مرد

!اس سے بہتر میں نہیں بیان کر سکتا تھا

 یہ ایسے ہے جیسے علمی بصیرتیں نتائج نہیں ہوتیں، بلکہ دعوتیں ہوتی ہیں۔

تو… آئیے گفتگو کھلی اور جاری رکھیں۔ 

:خاتون

!بلا شبہ

 اس پر میرے ساتھ تبصرہ اور نظرِ ثانی کرنے کا شکریہ۔

:مرد

ہمیشہ خوشی ہوتی ہے۔

…

5

  منٹ 26 سیکنڈ کی انگریزی آڈیو کے اردو ترجمہ کا اختتام

....


I made the following initial observations myself after listening to the original audio:

Overall, this AI powered 'Fireside Chat' was well summarised, although a bit more context could have been given to the public policy aspects of this action-oriented independent research and its utility for conflict resolution. 

The quest to make this public opinion survey as representative as possible could have been slightly elaborated on further too.

Other comments:

1) 09/01/2026 - Quayyum Raja - Politician/Psychologist - Khuiratta (Kotli)

It is very interesting, precise and imperative.

....

2) 09/01/2026 - Danish Manzoor - Social Activist - Rehara (Bagh)

(He was kind enough to present his initial comments in both Urdu and then in English too)

لاجواب جناب محترم تنویر صاحب۔

 آپ کی یہ تحقیق آزاد جموں و کشمیر کی تاریخ میں اپنی نوعیت کی سب سے بڑی طویل المدت اور عوامی بنیاد پر اٹھنے والی رائے شماری کے طور پر ایک نمایاں تحقیق ہے۔

 پانچ برس سے زائد عرصے پر محیط اس تحقیقی عمل میں آپ نے آزاد کشمیر کی تمام 32 تحصیلوں سے 10,000 ایسے شہریوں کی رائے شامل کی جو ریاستی شہریت (1927) کے تحت اہل تھے۔

آپ نے اس عظیم کام کو نہایت احسن طریقے سے انجام دیا ہے۔ آپ کی تحقیقی بصیرت علمیت اور تجزیاتی صلاحیتیں بلا شبہ غیر معمولی ہیں۔

میں آپ کو دل کی اتھاہ گہرائیوں سے مبارکباد پیش کرتا ہوں کہ جہاں آپ نے یہ بہترین تحقیق پیش کی ہے وہاں آپ نے ہمارے خطے کے اندر موجود فکری اور علمی ٹیلنٹ کو بھی اجاگر کیا ہے۔

بین الاقوامی معیار کی اس تحقیق کو پیش کر کے جناب نے یہ بھی ثابت کیا ہے کہ آزاد جموں و کشمیر محض ایک متنازعہ جغرافیہ نہیں ہے۔ یہ سنجیدہ باشعور اور باصلاحیت اذہان سے بھرا ہوا ایک زندہ سماج ہے۔

یہ تحقیق آپ نے ایک انتہائی مشکل پیچیدہ اور رکاوٹوں سے بھری ہوئی راہ میں انجام دی ہے۔ آپ نے اپنے قیمتی وقت اور توانائی کی بے پناہ قربانی دی اور عزم و استقلال کے ساتھ یہ کام مکمل کیا۔ یقینا آپ اس کوشش اور لگن کے لیے خراجِ تحسین کے مستحق ہیں۔

میں نے ابھی پوری رپورٹ کا مطالعہ نہیں کیا تاہم جو حصہ میں نے دیکھا اور پڑھا ہے وہ حیرت انگیز اور بے مثال ہے۔ یہ ایک شاندار تحقیقی کارنامہ ہے۔

 میں پوری رپورٹ کا بغور مطالعہ کرنے کے بعد اس پر اپنا مکمل نقطہ نظر اور تجزیاتی رائے ضرور پیش کروں گا۔

۔۔۔۔

Tremendous work Mr Tanveer Ahmed. 

Your research stands out as the largest, longest running and truly grassroots public opinion survey in the history of Azad Jammu & Kashmir. Spanning over five years, it encompasses the views of 10,000 citizens from all 32 tehsils of AJK, all of whom were eligible under the State Subject Rule of 1927.

This is truly remarkable work which has been carried out by you Mr. Tanveer Ahmed. Your investigative insight, scholarly rigour and analytical abilities are unquestionably exceptional. I extend my heartfelt congratulations to you for not only highlighting the intellectual and academic talent present within our region but also for producing a study of international standard. Through this work, you have demonstrated that Azad Jammu & Kashmir is not merely a disputed territory but a vibrant society filled with thoughtful, capable and highly skilled minds.

You completed this research under extremely challenging circumstances, overcoming numerous obstacles and dedicating immense time, energy and perseverance to see it through. You are unquestionably worthy of the highest praise and recognition for your effort and commitment.

I must acknowledge that I have not yet read the entire report but what I have seen and studied so far is truly outstanding and unparalleled; an extraordinary scholarly achievement. 

Once I have reviewed the full report, I will present my comprehensive perspective and analytical reflections on this exceptional work. I thank you Mr Tanveer for this remarkable work.

..

My brief response in Roman Urdu:

Bahut shukrya huzoor. Umeed hay ke deegar humwatan bhi is audio clip ko sunengey aur report bhi parengey. 

Ye sab kuch aik haqeeqi awaami hukumat ke qayaam ke liye ehem juz they aur is tehqeeq ke safar ne apna roadmap khud organically apney aap ko teh kiya.

....

3) 09/01/2026 - Barrister Asif Khan - Retired - Dadyaal (Mirpur) & Wolverhampton (UK)

Adabs to all, well said Danish Manzoor Sahib. Tanveer’s work is irreplaceable. He has spent 20 years trying to wake us all up but as always, we miss every opportunity.

Danish Manzoor's Response:

Absolutely Asif Sahib. There is no doubt that Tanveer's dedication and vision over the past 20 years is truly remarkable.

4) 09/01/2026 - Anonymous (UK)

Is it ok to share and circulate? Who's debating this in the audio?

My response (shared publicly):

Of course, it is to share and respond productively. 

The following is my initial review of it:

Overall, this AI powered 'Fireside Chat' was well summarised, although a bit more context could have been given to the public policy aspects of this action-oriented independent research and its utility for conflict resolution. 

The quest to make this public opinion survey as representative as possible, could have been slightly elaborated on further.

Tanveer Ahmed

JKA PUBLIC AGENCY Note: #EAF223209012026

....

Public Finance Update:

Number of co-citizens who have paid their share (over 20 years): 
16
Number of co-citizens who have paid a portion to date, since direct public funding began in 2012:
206
Number of co-citizens who have promised to pay:
85
Number of co-citizens I have directly contacted since the 9th of October 2025 (of total 5,000):
536

Cash in Hand: 92,360
Cash Deposits: 2,41,700
Immediate Debts: 0 

....

Daily Diary (DD) - Day 326 of 2026

1423hrs: Day 171 is more of the same, only with more intensity. There has been a marked increase in Pakistani security forces into AJK, incl...